Fans Spot Plot Holes in 'American Horror Stories: Bestie'

• The "Bestie" episode from American Horror Stories has become a beloved choice among fans, exploring powerful themes of isolation and digital society.
• Audiences have pointed out plot inconsistencies in "Bestie," raising doubts about how the character manages to survive in an deserted house.
• Even with several unresolved mysteries, "Bestie" stands out due to its compelling dark plot, much like many of the captivating installments within the show.

While some horror anthologies fail to introduce fresh perspectives to the conventions they examine, many do not fall into this category. American Horror Stories The episodes are a thrilling and entertaining journey. Though the episode The "Backrooms" fails to thoroughly explore the mythology it stems from. , the Season 3 episode titled "Bestie" is beloved by fans. . It streamed on FX on Hulu in October 2023 and starred Emma Halleen as Shelby Brubacker, a isolated teenager who gets involved with an online companion called Bestie (Jessica Barden).

Regardless of the number of seasons American Horror Stories Step outside, viewers are always eager to discuss "Bestie." They often delve into topics such as isolation, how digital environments impact teenagers, and dealing with loss, along with analyzing the surprising conclusion. I concur that this episode stands out strongly, and it’s certainly one that has lingered in my thoughts since my initial viewing. Nonetheless, having come across an inconsistency noted by a viewer, I am now equally persuaded of its flaws. One segment of the episode is confusing. .

Viewers Spotted an Error in the "Bestie" Episode of American Horror Stories and It Raises Several Queries

In a Reddit thread , a fan posed some thought-provoking questions about the American Horror Stories episode "Bestie" and wrote:

"How/why was bestie living in an abandoned housing project? How did she have electricity, water, or internet there? How did she get food?"

Redditor @Picabo07 replied:

I was curious about that as well. They kept many things unresolved there.

This is indeed an interesting observation, and upon reflection, I find myself considering the same question. It makes me ponder how Bestie manages to reside in this antiquated dwelling unnoticed. While that might seem somewhat far-fetched, it fails to detract from the overall quality of the episode. Nonetheless, It doesn't make sense that she would have internet access and power. It also appears improbable that she would possess sufficient funds to purchase food or clothing. Certainly, it’s conceivable, but not very likely. River Wallace (played by Allius Barnes), Shelby's romantic interest, whom Bestie manipulates brings her meals and various supplies. However, how much longer could this arrangement last, and since when has Bestie been acquainted with River? It’s possible that Bestie might have deceived numerous online acquaintances for an extended period, having them deliver goods to her. Yet, if that were true, the episode probably should have clarified these details.

Since several American Horror Stories episodes, like "Lake," involve the supernatural, I wished for some supernatural aspects in "Bestie." I think that would have helped explain any potential plot holes or confusing moments. Some fans have wondered if Bestie was actually dead the entire time, and I was wondering about that, too. If Bestie was a ghost, then perhaps she would have had the power to turn on the abandoned house's electricity and also set up an Internet connection. Sure, that might have been a bit corny, but I think it would have fit the tone of the episode.

Both "Bestie" and the Black Mirror Season 7 episode titled "Bête Noire" delve into intricate and, eventually, perilous relationships, yet I remain able to value "Bestie" for its contemplative narrative. One can readily choose to overlook the inquiries regarding internet connectivity and power supply and concentrate instead on the ominous path that Bestie charts for Shelby. Nonetheless, it would have been splendid if at least some of these uncertainties had received brief explanations.

Viewers Share Their Opinions on the Latest 'American Horror Stories' Episode Titled "Bestie"

While fans appreciate the American Horror Stories episode "Bestie," they have some criticisms of the storyline and characters. In another Reddit thread , a fan posted that they figured Bestie was offspring of Mr. Nevin (Jeff Hiller) the educator Several other spectators also had questions about this, and it could've been a major revelation. Someone else commented:

I'm really disappointed that we didn't learn anything about my buddy at all.

I concur that delving deeper into Bestie's background would have been intriguing, and although viewers learn certain aspects of her life, these details remain insufficient. another thread , a fan pondered whether there might be significant revelations concerning River and wrote:

I thought it would turn out that the guy was actually Bestie or that the best friend was somehow a manipulative spirit. Anybody else had this expectation?

I concur that by the conclusion of the episode, several queries remain unresolved. However, similar to The Season 3 episode titled "Tapeworm," "Bestie" is intriguing and spooky , and those are two aspects that I consistently seek in an episode of American Horror Stories .

Share this post